Employment – Claims – Overseas Worker
In the case Saggar v Ministry of Defence [2005], it was held that an overseas based employee of a British business, who was a UK resident when recruited or at any time during the course of the employee's employment, is entitled to bring a discrimination claim in the UK. The claim can be brought even if the employee did no further work in Britain after the move overseas.
After 16 years at a Ministry of Defence base in Britain, Lieutenant Colonel Surinder Nath Saggar was permanently stationed in Cyprus from 1998 and was still there when he made a claim for race discrimination.
The Employment Tribunal decided that Lieutenant Saggar worked wholly outside Britain and could not file a race discrimination claim in Britain. He appealed against this decision to the Employment Appeals Tribunal ("EAT").
The EAT dismissed the appeal and held that:-
▪ In order for Lieutenant Saggar's claim to succeed, the EAT would have to look at the whole of his employment from 1982 onwards, and that would be "absurd";
▪ The EAT was bound by the decision of the Court of Appeal in the case of Carver v Saudi Arabian Airlines [1999] where for the purposes of establishing whether or not a tribunal has jurisdiction to hear a claim, it is necessary to consider whether, at the time of the alleged discrimination, the claimant was wholly or mainly working in Great Britain;
▪ Accordingly, at the time of the alleged discrimination, Lieutenant Saggar worked wholly in Cyprus.
The case went to the Court of Appeal and it was decided that: -
▪ The relevant period for determining whether a claimant worked wholly or mainly outside Great Britain is the whole period of employment;
▪ This approach was supported by the wording in s 8(1) of the Race Relations Act 1976; and
▪ This decision applied equally to all employees even though a person serving in the Armed Forces is not an employee as there is no contract of service.
The matter was remitted to a different tribunal to determine the issue of jurisdiction in accordance with the Court of Appeal's judgment.
Comment: This is a significant decision in favour of employees. This means that in many cases where employees are posted abroad they are entitled to bring employment claims in the UK. In practice, as well as complying with the rules of the country where employees are working, it would be sensible for employers to apply English employment law standards as well. Please contact us for more information: enquiries@rtcoopers.com
© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.
Full service commercial law firm based in the City of London specialising in Employment Law, Employment Lawyers, Dismissals, Redundancies, Suspensions, Grievance and Disciplinary Procedures, Workplace Disuptes, Wrongful Dismissals, Breach of Contract, Business Secrets/Confidential Information, Contract Disputes, Drafting and Advising on Compromise Agreements, Drafting and Advising on Employment Contracts or Terms of Employment, Drafting and Advising on Staff Handbook and other Policy Documents, Employment Tribunal Claims, Employment Termination, Employee Benefits and Incentives, Equal Pay Disputes, Restructuring and Re-organisations, Senior Executive Appointments and Service Agreements, Sex Discrimination, Sexual Harassment, Sexual Orientation Issues, TUPE Transfers
If you have an employment question, please contact Rosanna at enquiries@rtcoopers.com. We have a number of employment legal uodates on our website at: http://www.rtcoopers.com/practice_employment.php
Related Articles:
A Resume for Disaster.. How Not to Land a Work at Home Job
After running a successful telecommuting site for over 8 years and an employment agency before that, I still get that one question over and over. "Why have I not been able to land a work at home job?" My first answer is always the same. "Let's look at your resume."
Nationally Recognized Nutritional Expert Joel Fuhrman, M.D. Now Ads Talk Radio Show Host to His Resume with his Insightful and Information Rich Show &
Nationally Recognized Nutritional Expert Joel Fuhrman, M.D. now ads talk radio show host to his resume with his insightful and information rich show "Nutritional Wisdom" with Dr. Fuhrman debuting on the VoiceAmericaTM Network**
Interviewing an Author: Dont Be Left Speechless
Joyce Carol Oates. Langston Hughes.
Sutherland Global Services, BPO Provider, Adds Jobs in Canada
Sutherland Global Services, Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) Provider, plans to add jobs in Canada by expanding its Vernon, BC location.
Nursing Agency Jobs
The time is now for entrepreneurs to start a nursing agency, nursing registry business, operate a homecare business or as a medical recruiter or just become an independent healthcare contractor. How to Start a Nursing Agency Guide Books are flooding the internet.
How To Write A Resume Using Your Resume to Secure Your Dream Job
Most of us have the misconception that our curriculum vitae or resume is just a simple document that lists our educational/work background and contact information. However, if you really want to land the job of your dreams, you must learn how to write a resume professionally.
Sample Resume Objectives: Read, Dont Copy
The resume objective statement is typically something that trips people up.Confronted by the silent challenge of the blank page, most folks Google for "sample resume objectives".
IPCPR Believes Maryland Smoking Ban Puts Jobs, Businesses, Non-Profits at Risk
Maryland's ban on smoking in public places goes into effect Feb. 1. State tobacconists fear their businesses are at stake as are jobs and the charities their businesses help support. Is it long before more states follow suit?
HireRight Releases Key Enhancements to I-9 Solution: Employment Eligibility Solution Gives Employers Big Picture View,
Integration into Talent
In response to increasing enforcement, audits and penalties relating to I-9 employment eligibility by U.S. government agencies, HireRight, Inc. (Nasdaq: HIRE), a leader in on-demand employment screening, has announced a newly enhanced edition of the HireRight I-9 Solution, the on-demand product first introduced in 2007. The new version of the HireRight I-9 Solution addresses employers' need for greater visibility, control and flexibility over I-9 processes, across the enterprise, as government regulations and penalties related to employment eligibility stiffen.
Acquiring a Credible Employment Lawyer
The growing number employer-employee disputes in California also lead to an increasing figure of labor related cases filed in courts. In addition, with the civil rights of the workers threatened to be violated by those self-serving and intimidating employers, more and more law firms have engaged in the legal arena to provide their services to those who will seek of protection and legal representation. Giving their pledge of a speedy resolution in their clients? court cases, these law firms promotes different strategies to further sell their legal services in order to survive in the business; from imparting free legal advises to offering the cheapest professional fee just to acquire the largest portion of these justice-seekers. Some other fi...
Career Planning, Resume Writing and Leadership Development Company Announces Web Site Launch
Career Coaching 360 announces the launch of its company Web site, CareerCoaching360.com. A career planning, resume writing and leadership development company, Career Coaching 360 provides services for professionals and executives wanting to accelerate their careers. The new Web site provides details of the various services, tools and resources that the company offers. Founder Sherri Thomas will be a featured speaker presenting "Six Key Strategies to Accelerate Your Career" at the upcoming American Marketing Association's Annual Leadership Summit in Chicago on April 20.
Massage ? One Form of Necessary Sports Jobs?
We know that not everyone has the physical and mental talents needed to become a professional athlete. So what?s the next best thing? Why, sports jobs that constantly bring you into contact with professional athletes, of course. And one of the most necessary of sports jobs is being a massage therapist for professional athletes.
HireMeNow.com Launches First Online Temporary Employment Marketplace
HireMeNow.com fundamentally improves upon the way traditional temporary staffing services are delivered, by moving the business model completely online, and taking advantage of the growing acceptance of video resumes. Companies can post jobs for free and select temporary candidates directly, saving time and money. Job candidates can apply to jobs for free, completing their profile and taking skills tests from the convenience of their homes .
Helping Others to Help Themselves: Graduates Jobs in Recruiting
Graduates who are looking for jobs in the United Kingdom will often consult with job recruiting firms to help find temporary and permanent work. These young professionals will be put through application, assessment, and placement processes before they find their perfect job. However, many graduates seem to forget about a job opportunity that is right in front of their faces. Job recruiting firms are constantly seeking young professionals for recruiting, training, and assessment positions in order to appeal to the graduate classes that come out of United Kingdom universities every year.
How You Can Find Freelance Editing Jobs
Freelance editing opportunities are out there, you just need to know where and how to look for them. As a matter of fact, there are hundreds of companies that are waiting for you, right now, to fill their job vacancies.