Employment Law: Can You Stop Employees ?preparing? To Compete?
The relationship between employer and employee is founded on a continuing bond of trust and confidence. In relation to this, the terms ?duty of fidelity? and ?fiduciary duties? have arisen in relation to employees and directors respectively. These terms have been around for many years but defining the extent of these duties remains a challenge.
All employees owe a ?duty of fidelity? to their employer, requiring them to act in good faith when executing their contractual duties. In addition, directors owe ?fiduciary duties?, requiring them to positively act in the best interests of the company and, unlike ordinary employees, even disclose their own misdeeds. Directors? fiduciary duties are distinct from, and go beyond, the duty of fidelity owed by all employees.
In an interesting recent development, two similar cases have provided useful guidance on the scope of these implied duties and the degree to which they may restrict an employee who is preparing to go into competition with his or her employer. The judgments, whilst reaching opposite conclusions on their facts, provide a useful insight into this area of law.
The Sliding Scale
In Shepherds Investments Ltd v Walters, the Court of Appeal indicated that there was sliding scale of behaviour in respect of an employee?s preparations to establish a competing business. The precise point at which such actions become unlawful (i.e. breach the duty of fidelity or a fiduciary duty) will turn on the facts of the particular case. At one end of the scale ?merely making a decision to set up a competing business at some point in the future and discussing it with friends and family? would not constitute a breach. At the other end of the spectrum, ?soliciting customers of the company?or the actual carrying on of trade by a competing business? would be a clear breach of duty. The area in between was left open for future judicial interpretation.
On the facts of this case, directors and senior employees were held to be in breach of their fiduciary duties and obligations of fidelity by promoting their own competing business whilst still employed. Interestingly, the Court was quite prepared to extend the scope of ?fiduciary duties? to senior employees who were not formally directors (i.e. employees parading as ?sales director? or ?marketing director? etc, but who are not registered office holders). It might come as surprise to those concerned that the designation of such a title carries with it the more stringent duties a fiduciary.
The Importance of Drafting
In Helmet Integrated Systems Ltd v Tunnard, the Court of Appeal went one step further, describing a ?middle-ranking? senior salesman as a fiduciary on the basis of his activities ? it being part of his duties to advise on competition with the employer?s business and the employer being dependent upon him to pass on such information. In essence, therefore, the test for a ?fiduciary? is one of function rather than status.
In this case, the employee had taken preparatory steps whilst remaining employed, to market his own safety helmet in competition with his employer. However, despite ruling that the employee owed fiduciary duties, the Court did not accept that these preparatory steps were sufficient to constitute a breach of those duties. According to the Court: ?Clear words are needed to restrict the ordinary freedom of an employee who is considering setting up in competition to his former employer? and wish ?to assess the viability of the concept?.
Comment
These cases will be welcomed by employers for extending the coverage of fiduciary duties to a broader range of employees. However, the cases also emphasise the importance of clear contractual drafting. Whilst many employers include post-termination restrictive covenant in their standard contracts of employment, a restriction on ?preparatory acts? whilst still in employment is far less common.
Should you require assistance in drafting or implementing such restrictions, the Michelmores? Employment Team will be happy to help.
AND IN OTHER NEWS:
Legislation coming into force in April 2007?
From 1 April:
The basic rate of maternity pay, paternity pay and adoption pay increases to ?112.75.
From 6 April:
Statutory sick pay increases to ?72.55
The Sex Discrimination Act 1975 is amended to place a statutory duty on all public authorities to eliminate unlawful discrimination and harassment and promote equality of opportunity between men and women.
The Information and Consultation Regulations are extended to cover employers with 100 or more employees
The Flexible Working Regulations are extended to include carers of adults.
And on the horizon?
The Employment Retention Bill had its first reading in the House of Commons on 13th March 2007 and is due to have its second reading on 18th May 2007. The Bill makes provision for a statutory right to rehabilitation leave (disability leave) for newly disabled people and for people whose existing impairments change.
Tim Davies http://employment.michelmores.com/pages/team.asp is an Associate Solicitor at Michelmores Solicitors http://employment.michelmores.com in the Employment Law Department. Contact Tim on tjd@michelmores.com for info.
Related Articles:
Do I Need a Resume to Find An At-Home Job?
Depending on the type of at-home job you want to find, you might still need to have a resume, especially if you are going to be providing a business-profession-type service. For at-home businesses that involve providing other non-professional services, you probably need only a business brochure or other printed information materials.
Travel Nursing Jobs and Travel Allied Health Jobs Provider Medical Solutions Ranks No. 625 on 2007 Inc. 5,000 with Three-year Sales Growth of 519%
Traveling healthcare staffing company Medical Solutions, Inc. is proud to announce its inclusion in Inc. magazine's first-ever Inc. 5,000 list of the fastest-growing private companies in the country. Medical Solutions, a provider of nationwide travel nursing jobs and travel allied health jobs, is the fifth fastest growing company in Nebraska. Medical Solutions ranked No. 625 overall and No. 10 out of all the healthcare staffing firms making the list.
Finding Administrative Jobs In The IT Field
Information technology firms, consultancies, and other companies thrive on IT professionals who are able to do a variety of tasks in a single day. While these professionals work on the front lines of the global economy in the 21st century, there is an equal need for administrators and managers who can organize these professionals into efficient working groups. IT administrators, managers, and executives typically are developed in house from positions as diverse as help desk operation and software development. In this way, administrators understand the perspective of their subordinates while maintaining a larger view of where the company is heading in the future.
Computer Software Engineer Jobs In The UK
The field of Computer Software Engineering has become more popular among UK university graduates in recent years. Students are entering university with a more sophisticated knowledge of information technology than undergraduates from a generation ago. This knowledge is coupled with a realisation that many of the best jobs available in the UK involve computer technology, creating a desire within university students for success in the IT world. However, as graduates leave the university setting for the professional world, they begin to realise that their dream of working as a computer software engineer may be difficult to achieve.
Hand Surgeon Jobs
The job market for hand surgeons has always been stable and there is always a regular supply of hand surgeon jobs. Every year, there are numerous new hand surgery job openings that absorb all the hand surgeons who complete their training.
The BrandonWayne Group Launches CallCenterClassifieds.com 'The Premier Call Center Employment and Industry Services Website'
The BrandonWayne Group, a leading provider of call center recruiting services and programs, announced today the launch of Phase One of www.CallCenterClassifieds.com, the Call Center Industry's Premier Employment and Resource Website.
Save Money by Grouping all Your Electrical Repair Jobs Together
Many people are greatly concerned regarding the total cost they will need to spend to have their electrical projects completed. One great way homeowners and business owners can save money on electrical repair jobs is to group the projects together and have the electrician perform all of the work at one time. The best way to ensure that you have all of your electrical needs repaired at once is to make a thorough investigation of your electrical problems and have them fixed immediately.
Helping Others to Help Themselves: Graduates Jobs in Recruiting
Graduates who are looking for jobs in the United Kingdom will often consult with job recruiting firms to help find temporary and permanent work. These young professionals will be put through application, assessment, and placement processes before they find their perfect job. However, many graduates seem to forget about a job opportunity that is right in front of their faces. Job recruiting firms are constantly seeking young professionals for recruiting, training, and assessment positions in order to appeal to the graduate classes that come out of United Kingdom universities every year.
Interviewing - The Single Most Important Question To Ask
When prospective employees are being interviewed, they are asked about their past employment. But they are usually asked about what they did. These answers may be shaded to reflect a well..... favorable impression. Sometimes the answers won't be truthful. Don't you really want to know how well they are going to get along with you and your group after they've been hired?
Employment Podcast: Having Trouble Dealing With Your Boss - Your Job - Your Life? Julie Jansen, Speaker, Career Coach and Author Can Help
In today's job market, successful career management requires a "well-planned, strategic approach." In a new career development podcast on Total Picture Radio, Julie Jansen describes real-world methods for achieving work and life goals.
Hundreds of HR Professionals Gather for Nation?s Most Dynamic and Valuable Employment Law Conference
Leading employment law attorneys to explain at two-day symposium how HR professionals should adjust policies in light of new laws, court decisions, and regulations. 13th annual event delivers practical, real-world answers to questions about FMLA, discrimination, harassment, union organizing, documentation, and much more.
Considering Flight Jobs Throughout The World
When the average student or young professional thinks about the flight industry, they typically think of major carriers that fly international routes. After all, commercials and the use of these airlines by millions of passengers per year make it all but impossible not to think of them when provoked. However, potential flight professionals need to consider the bigger picture when thinking about the flight job market. There are many jobs for companies big and small throughout the world, with a job to fit almost any personal or professional need. As well, pilots and other flight professionals who want to see different parts of the world can find work almost anywhere. Pilots and mechanics alike have special skills that set them apart from the ...
Employment Law - Workplace Bullying
Workplace bullying has been with us ever since the advent of the Industrial Revolution. Interestingly in New South Wales the Office of Industrial Relations of the NSW Department of Commerce provides scant information about this anti-social workplace behaviour. Research indicates that workplace bullying is widespread and that it is more prevalent that harassment. What is also interesting is that in New South Wales there is no statutory definition of bullying. In point of fact Butterworths Australian Legal Dictionary is also mute on this point. The Law Society of NSW has offered the following definition of bullying: "Unreasonable and inappropriate workplace behaviour includes bullying, which comprises behaviour which intimidates, offend...
Pharmaceutical Sales Jobs for UK Graduates
The average day of a pharmaceutical sales representative can be long but rewarding. In the morning, sales professionals attend meetings with their sales managers to discuss their call sheet and any sales appointments that they have for the day. As well, these meetings can include sales quotas, company information, and motivational techniques to keep sales people on their game. Sales people begin their day in earnest by making calls to hospital administrators, doctors, and other medical professionals to discuss their company?s products. Business lunches and office visits to returning clients are necessary for sales people to close sales. Paperwork and returning phone calls late in the day finishes off the day for salespeople. The typical day...
Unemployed People with Disabilities Offered Flexible Employment Opportunity in Tough Economy
Disaboom, the Premiere Online Community for People Touched by Disability, Employs Community Members in Newly Launched Sales Force: In the face of tough economic conditions, Disaboom (OTCBB: DSBO; www.disaboom.com), the largest online community designed for people touched by disabilities, has taken a unique step by hiring its own online community members. Disaboom's new program, the Marketplace Opportunity Brokers (MOB), offers highly flexible, commission paying jobs that not only fit the lifestyle of people touched by disabilities but also provide an attractive source of full-time or supplemental income for anyone looking for flexible employment.